Just a little bit of fun inspired by Sol's topic on better OO gauge track.
Please note that this is not meant to be a heavily serious debate, just an interesting interlude.

It would be interesting if you could also answer the following question with a straight Yes / No. (please do not discuss the issue on this poll thread) :-

If an OO /HO track system was made by Peco or Hornby, which had a better scale appearance, would you use it :?:

YES.

Yes from me for a better alternative.

yes

Yes.

yes iwould.    8)

definately yes

cheers Brian.W

As one who uses mainly Atlas Code 100 track, with some Code 75 in certain sidings, I cannot vote or comment here.  But a general observation is that I would always try to balance the best quality and prototypical track with the price.  BUT … I'm not going to spend a fortune to get absolutely precise sleepers or spikes - money that could be better spent in general modelling :D

A provisional yes, but I would have to see it first.  I currently use Tillig which I am happy with so any change would have to be to something better.

yes

YES

YES

YES

Petermac

Maybe!
It depends on what (if any) modifications are made to their points and crossings.
I admit to using Peco code 75 on Pen-Y-Bont but, this was not my prefered choice. I would have liked to have used SMP or C&L but, I just haven't got the time to assemble the points etc. It's taken ages to get as far as I have as it is!
As for Tillig, never seen it in the flesh but as far as I can tell it's still HO so incorrect sleeper spacing for 00 gauge and I believe it is code 83 as well so too heavy for my branch line terminus.
 But. You pays your money and you take your choice.

No

Yes.

Perry

No

I have laid too much of the other stuff.  I would if I was starting a new layout from afresh.

Bob(K)

No

Wayne

Just as an additional bit of useless info.

I have always wondered about the term when used with slips - inside & outside slips. Well, my query was answered yesterday at the Exhibition here in South Aust. A dealer, Orient Express, had on display Tillig track & points- H0, which of course can be & has been used for OK 00 stock, had on display a first class piece of track work.

Outside double slip



As it maybe seen, the blades/tiebars are right at the end of unit making it an outside slip & has a radius of around 40 inches.

The Peco Code 75 slip has inside blades with a radius of 24 inches



UK price variation betwen both types is about 6 pounds.