Hornby B12/3 problems

Post

Posted
Rating:
#263041 (In Topic #14336)
Avatar
Full Member

Hornby Service Centre come to the rescue


About 4 years ago, I bought a new Hornby B12/3 to replace an old version that I remember having as a boy and which I bought "just for historic purposes" a bit earlier (The one with the sandpaper chuff-chuff noise!).  She is seen above on the old Yarslow layout in London - all nice and shiny and red, hauling a Kirk Gresley 3rd.  The old version is half-hidden on the right of shot.

Recently, on the new layout, she came a dead stop for no apparent reason.  I had a quick look for any obvious signs of trouble and finding none, put her back on the track where she ran another 6 feet before stopping again.

A full investigation revealed nothing obvious - motor, tender electrics, PCB all looked OK.  A quick on-line search produced a thread on RMweb about B12's stopping.  It turns out that there are issues with dry joints on the PCB in the tender and a simple re-soldering job would cure it.

Now, I have learned to solder wires to switches and other components BUT wiring tiny wires to a PCB? - no.

I called the Hornby Customer Helpline and spoke to a very helpful guy who knew that "there had been some on-line traffic" about this issue.  He promised a Warrenty repair and suggested a couple of weeks turnaround.

I'm not easily impressed by big companies and their promises but I was very pleased with the way Hornby handled this.  I shall send the loco off tomorrow and let you know what occcurs…………….

Last edit: by Barry Miltenburg


Shed dweller, Softie Southerner and Meglomaniac
Online now: No Back to the top

Post

Posted
Rating:
#263095
Avatar
Full Member
I've never had direct dealings with Hornby Barry but I have with Bachmann and have always found their service department extremely helpful - if a little expensive sometimes with their "standard" price for spares - £1 for a tiny screw (plus postage of course) !!

Good luck with the loco - I too had one of those sandpaper chuff versions and very effective it was.   :thumbs

'Petermac
Online now: No Back to the top

Post

Posted
Rating:
#263244
Avatar
Full Member


She's back

After what Hornby have described as "a new capacitor and PCB", 61533 has been returned to traffic free of charge and running well.  She has had a dozen laps of the main line and looks just fine.

Whilst it can be a disappointment to have a new engine fail, I can only applaud Hornby for their polite helpfulness and willingness to effect a repair.  The whole process took about a week, door to door.

Net cost to me was the £8 I spent on postage - she went back to Hornby via insured/signed-for post.

Barry

Shed dweller, Softie Southerner and Meglomaniac
Online now: No Back to the top

Post

Posted
Rating:
#263246
Full Member
Hurray. Hope it continues to run well from now on!
Online now: No Back to the top

Post

Posted
Rating:
#263263
Avatar
Full Member
That's a brilliant outcome Barry - well done Hornby.   :thumbs

How does she run compared with the sandpaper version ?

'Petermac
Online now: No Back to the top

Post

Posted
Rating:
#263271
Avatar
Full Member
Beer and crisps Peter!

I have an old one - bought for pure nostalgia - and despite having lost its phosphor bronze strip under the tender, runs like a whale in custard  :cry:

The new one, although a bit noisy when starting and stopping, is smooth and powerful.  The only thing missing from the DC version is the chuff-chuff noise!!

I can hear it in my head of course……….

Shed dweller, Softie Southerner and Meglomaniac
Online now: No Back to the top
1 guest and 0 members have just viewed this.