Tutorial Blocks and Stop Markers
Posted
#102565
(In Topic #5452)
Full Member
Comments /crticism……whatever
Posted
Full Member
When discussing multiple BS marker i think it would be an idea to have screenshot of the block with muliple BS markers shown in one direction.
Secondly can you just clarify the obvious that if the BS markers are to react to a signal they need to stop the train prior to the signal, i.e. if its a block that generally will only be used for passing through, if the next block is occupied then it must have BS markers relative to the signal position.
Its a masterpiece John you should publish it when its done, ask Ian Morton who he uses!
Regards
Pete.
ECOS2 with RR&Co Traincontroller and a load of other electronics so i can sit back and watch the trains go by.
Pete.
ECOS2 with RR&Co Traincontroller and a load of other electronics so i can sit back and watch the trains go by.
Posted
Full Member
Thats great John, just a few points at the end would it be worth having a screenshot of the switchboard so the "trainee" can see what he should have built now?
I did a separate post I should merge/duplicate them
When discussing multiple BS marker i think it would be an idea to have screenshot of the block with muliple BS markers shown in one direction.
Will do
Secondly can you just clarify the obvious that if the BS markers are to react to a signal they need to stop the train prior to the signal, i.e. if its a block that generally will only be used for passing through, if the next block is occupied then it must have BS markers relative to the signal position.
You are absolutely correct…..will do
Signals, I am afraid, are purely decorative on Granby so the treatment of signals in the tutorial is extremely sparse
I wonder if I should post a marker dealing with signalling the tutorial layout before I go on to transfer the engine section……by marker I just mean an almost blank post so it will be in the correct order……the problem is should they be light or mock semaphore…….light would be easiest? What do you guys think:
Regards
Posted
Full Member
Pete
Regards
Pete.
ECOS2 with RR&Co Traincontroller and a load of other electronics so i can sit back and watch the trains go by.
Pete.
ECOS2 with RR&Co Traincontroller and a load of other electronics so i can sit back and watch the trains go by.
Posted
Full Member
I have made the other changes you suggested…..and many thanks again
Posted
Guest user
Brian is right, signals are a nightmare. they can be done a number of ways, i think i done it the hard way. i am still in the building mode and haven't been in the shed for over a month. this weekend should see me brushing away the cobwebs on the toolbox.:roll:
Posted
Guest user
I am in favour of setting up a blank framework and basing it on the tutorial layout would give us a starting point. Initially I think it should be based on colour lights - the triggers, enabled trains, conditions etc. would not vary much on converting to working semaphores for those who can make them. Because we are all, I think, learning as we go I would like it to be open as a discussion topic before we get anywhere near the tutorial format.Signals, I am afraid, are purely decorative on Granby so the treatment of signals in the tutorial is extremely sparse
I wonder if I should post a marker dealing with signalling the tutorial layout before I go on to transfer the engine section……by marker I just mean an almost blank post so it will be in the correct order……the problem is should they be light or mock semaphore…….light would be easiest? What do you guys think:
I get the impression that we are all looking at signalling our layouts but not quite sure how to set about it. I am certain that pooling what we have each done so far will get us moving.
Choosing sub categories is tricky. What do you think about splitting it into positions: Home signals, starters, block signals on plain track, shunting, calling-on, junctions, and so on? Taking one type at a time would help make sense of the simple signals before having to cope with the really difficult bits.
Posted
Full Member
Its an interesting problem and one I have been stalling
One issue should we assume the reader has a basic knowledge of signalling practice (there are already some excellent sources here) and focus on how to incoporate some basic signalling into our trial layout?
I was thinking of waiting until I got to the end and then starting a signalling sequence as a series of posts.
At this stage the tutorial layout breaks down into 3 stages……………(its probably time we expanded it) but for now we have
[1] The simple branch with a loop
[2] The terminus to the branch with a mid journey halt
[3] A three platform terminus with a loco spur, the original branch and a second branch
I was thinking of going through the basics with layout 1 then move forward in easy stages
I agree we need to thrash it out here first……my interlocking skills are zero
Regards
Posted
Guest user
Going through your post, I think the tutorial should deal only with making TC work the signals and related issues with interlocking and protection. As you say, there are lots of resources to guide on how to place signals and everyone's needs will be different.
I don't want to affect your plans for writing the tutorial, but I am at the stage of working out TC signalling operations for my own layout from a base of very little knowledge and no experience. To clarify my own ideas it would be helpful to start a discussion at this stage and the others may well be in the same position. What do you think, Pete, Matt, Max, Geoff and anyone else out there?
That raises a much more fundamental point: Are we, the current readers, simply waiting to follow the results of your hard work, research and decision making or should we be actively contributing? I am learning how to deal with TC by pitching in and trying things out, my file of discarded trial layouts is becoming embarassingly large, and I expect everyone has the same approach. I think we could all benefit by pooling our ideas.
Dividing the tutorial layout into 3 or more pieces of increasing difficulty for signalling sounds like a good scheme but would need your decisions on the signal placement and methods of operation.
To move on, would anyone be interested and/or willing to contribute if I started a topic labelled "Signalling with TC" much on the lines of Max's shunting puzzle, attempting to thrash out between us anyone's TC signalling problems?
Regards,
Brian
Posted
Inactive Member
I know diddly about signalling, so I'm not going to be much help. My expertise (what there is of it), is in the sound part of it - more particularly with Loksound. I know nothing much about how railways use signals (Christrerise and Gwiwer are the guyz for that), so I was planning to just put up some quesswork signals and try to fire them with TC.
I'm afraid I'm a bit of a lurker with all this stuff. :oops:
I don't know what I don't know yet.
Max
Port Elderley
Port Elderley
Posted
Guest user
[user=269]MaxSouthOz[/user] wrote:
That's the only bit I want to look at in a new topic. We will all need to make our own decisions about what signals to use, where to put them and what we want them to do, with help from wherever we can get it. I know about as much as you on that.try to fire them with TC.
Implementing those decisions in TC is a whole new set of problems and that's where I think we need to put our heads together in the TC section.
Regards,
Brian
Posted
Full Member
That raises a much more fundamental point: Are we, the current readers, simply waiting to follow the results of your hard work, research and decision making or should we be actively contributing? I am learning how to deal with TC by pitching in and trying things out, my file of discarded trial layouts is becoming embarassingly large, and I expect everyone has the same approach. I think we could all benefit by pooling our ideas.
I had always hoped that the tutorial/FAQ would be a collective operation.
It has a sort of inherent logic in that everything leads towards the engine run around. Once it is reposted I would like to collectively add either new projects or new solutions
Going through your post, I think the tutorial should deal only with making TC work the signals and related issues with interlocking and protection. As you say, there are lots of resources to guide on how to place signals and everyone's needs will be different.
AGREED
Dividing the tutorial layout into 3 or more pieces of increasing difficulty for signalling sounds like a good scheme but would need your decisions on the signal placement and methods of operation.
Not my decisions……a joint consensus……then once agreed I could post the final version/narrative into the tutorial
I think that is a great idea……. So we have common ground I have posted the very first layout in a separate discrete thread…………the challenge is now to work out how to signal it!I don't want to affect your plans for writing the tutorial, but I am at the stage of working out TC signalling operations for my own layout from a base of very little knowledge and no experience. To clarify my own ideas it would be helpful to start a discussion at this stage and the others may well be in the same position. What do you think, Pete, Matt, Max, Geoff and anyone else out there?
Count me in………….To move on, would anyone be interested and/or willing to contribute if I started a topic labelled "Signalling with TC" much on the lines of Max's shunting puzzle, attempting to thrash out between us anyone's TC signalling problems?
Posted
Full Member
However i have had a go, for my platform starter signals i have connected them in parallel to the block signals i.e, when those little siganls at the end of the block go green my platform starter signal will go green as well hope fully. When you double click the block signal you will find it opens a good old TC properties box and heyho you can assign a dcc output! as well as 7,000 other things and rules.
We need to discuss hardware, i have ordered some LDT units for my signals which are light signals, but i guess for semaphores a good old point decoder will suffice?
Bite size pieces, maybe we should start with the layout and get one of our experts to signal it then we can get going.
Whichever way i am in.
Regards
Pete.
ECOS2 with RR&Co Traincontroller and a load of other electronics so i can sit back and watch the trains go by.
Pete.
ECOS2 with RR&Co Traincontroller and a load of other electronics so i can sit back and watch the trains go by.
Posted
Inactive Member
Max
Port Elderley
Port Elderley
Posted
Full Member
So Max, when we get TC operating semaphore signals correctly, can you help us with a sound file to generate that wonderful "clonk" as the arm returns to its "on" position??Hi Brian
I know diddly about signalling, so I'm not going to be much help. My expertise (what there is of it), is in the sound part of it - more particularly with Loksound. I know nothing much about how railways use signals (Christrerise and Gwiwer are the guyz for that), so I was planning to just put up some quesswork signals and try to fire them with TC.
I'm afraid I'm a bit of a lurker with all this stuff. :oops:
I don't know what I don't know yet.
Posted
Inactive Member
Max
Port Elderley
Port Elderley
Posted
Full Member
Posted
Inactive Member
Max
Port Elderley
Port Elderley
Posted
Full Member
Thats a good point Geoff because the possibities are endless and what i would class as background sounds ..cor you could have a field day with them.:cool:
Regards
Pete.
ECOS2 with RR&Co Traincontroller and a load of other electronics so i can sit back and watch the trains go by.
Pete.
ECOS2 with RR&Co Traincontroller and a load of other electronics so i can sit back and watch the trains go by.
Posted
Full Member
At this point, I'm interested in what hardware we need. Obviously we need some signals, but do we need more detectors or other gizmos - how are the signals powered? etc. etc.
The choice is wether you are having semaphores or lights Max, semaphores you could use tortoise or cobalts:thud, chill Max don't throw that at me.
For lights i am using the board from LDT for the ECOS which just runs off the track bus, there are several depends on the prototype signal.
http://www.ldt-infocenter.com/english/lsdec_ns_e.htm
LDT products for Lenz
http://www.ldt-infocenter.com/english/products_lenz-digital-plus_e.htm
Last edit: by wogga
Regards
Pete.
ECOS2 with RR&Co Traincontroller and a load of other electronics so i can sit back and watch the trains go by.
Pete.
ECOS2 with RR&Co Traincontroller and a load of other electronics so i can sit back and watch the trains go by.
1 guest and 0 members have just viewed this.