Video Archive         Recent Topics      
YMR logo

You are here:  Your Model Railway Club > Getting You Started. > Electrics - DCC > DCC - Tutorials > Fitting Decoders To bottom of page
                 

 Moderated by: Spurno  
AuthorPost
toto
Former Member
 

Joined: 
Location:  
Posts: 
Status: 
Offline

My photos:
view photos in Gallery
view photos as slides

I have started this thread as I have a number of loco's that need decoders fitted and as I'm not too confident of tinkering with certain types.

there is a list of various classes that will be victims over time on my main Rosebuddy thread which I shall shift over on to this one once I get a more accurate and updated list together when I get home on Friday night.

this thread serves two real purposes to me. One, hopefully as Max southoz suggested, anyone who has the knowledge of "how to" fit to a specific class might assist me by talking me through it which in turn, I shall try to provide photographs to back up the posts and hopefully it can act as a reference of sorts for others.

secondly, it gives me something to be getting on with whilst I work away from home. There at least 20 odds to do, probably more and they cover a variety of classes.

Have a look on the list and let me know if there are any particular items that would be of help / interest.

I can only keep this thread going at the pace that I can afford the decoders so it will be over time, but, I hope to keep a reasonably steady stream coming through until the deed is done at which point, anybody can feel free to keep it running with items that have not been covered.

I hope this thread proves useful and of interest.

any comments or suggestions on how I can improve on the above would be gratefully received.

cheers

toto

Sol
A modelling Moderator.


Joined: Mon Nov 28th, 2011
Location: Evanston Gardens, South Aust, Australia
Posts: 4056
Status: 
Offline

My photos:
view photos in Gallery
view photos as slides

Toto, have a look at
https://clarahost.clara.net/www.bromsgrovemodels.co.uk/decoderinstallation4mm.htm

toto
Former Member
 

Joined: 
Location:  
Posts: 
Status: 
Offline

My photos:
view photos in Gallery
view photos as slides

Thanks Sol,

A great resource. Looks like there's no point in me trying to reinvent the wheel then. :mutley

I think this post can come to a close. :mutley

Toto

Petermac
Moderator


Joined: Sat Oct 13th, 2007
Location: Nr Bergerac, France
Posts: 17028
Status: 
Offline

My photos:
view photos in Gallery
view photos as slides

No it can't Toto - John at Bromsgrove hasn't got them all in there and, last time I looked, some of the linked ones didn't connect ..............:cry::cry:

I'll look at your list in the layout thread to see what you've got but I'm sure there are some that could do with refreshing ..............:roll:


toto
Former Member
 

Joined: 
Location:  
Posts: 
Status: 
Offline

My photos:
view photos in Gallery
view photos as slides

Hi Petermac,

I looked at The list of loco's covered and did note that some of the classes covered were either hard wired versions or older models etc.

I'm more than happy to cover any that people will find of use so the post is re-opened provided there is enough interest for it.

I've just bought 9 x 21 pin decoders ( 4 x Lenz Silver and 5 x Hattons own ).

So what I would ask is that people initially try and ask for something which requires a 21 pin decoder. I will buy some 8 pin and a couple of 6 pin ( for class 03's ) over the next few weeks.

Any comments / views....... Welcome.

Cheers

Toto

BromsMods
Full Member


Joined: Mon Oct 15th, 2007
Location:  
Posts: 515
Status: 
Offline

My photos:
view photos in Gallery
view photos as slides

Petermac wrote: No it can't Toto - John at Bromsgrove hasn't got them all in there and, last time I looked, some of the linked ones didn't connect ..............:cry::cry:

I'll look at your list in the layout thread to see what you've got but I'm sure there are some that could do with refreshing ..............:roll:




Can you be specific Peter?  PM me with links if you can.  It does take some time to go through a website and check links - unfortunately people move their resources or the website just disappears.  Dapol, for example, have removed all of their N gauge guides.  I was told these would be reinstated "soon" but that was months ago!!

Of course, if anyone has installation guides they have done and they are for locos not already in our listings then you could forward them to us for inclusion and we will host the resource.  After all, as Toto has said, there's no point in reinventing the wheel!

Petermac
Moderator


Joined: Sat Oct 13th, 2007
Location: Nr Bergerac, France
Posts: 17028
Status: 
Offline

My photos:
view photos in Gallery
view photos as slides

I'll see if I can remember those that didn't connect John. :thumbs

I thought you'd gone off for a life of leisure in the Caribbean or something and assumed your guides were now just a legacy. :cheers

toto
Former Member
 

Joined: 
Location:  
Posts: 
Status: 
Offline

My photos:
view photos in Gallery
view photos as slides

Hi John,

I will hopefully be starting my first decoder installation this weekend providing my decoders have arrived from Hattons. ( ordered yesterday )

I will include photo's and be as specific and clear as I can. If the posts are any good and clear enough in a manner that makes them useable, by all means help yourself.

I am a complete novice at this so I think I would wait and see the results first. :mutley

Cheers anyway

Toto

BromsMods
Full Member


Joined: Mon Oct 15th, 2007
Location:  
Posts: 515
Status: 
Offline

My photos:
view photos in Gallery
view photos as slides

Petermac wrote: I'll see if I can remember those that didn't connect John. :thumbs

I thought you'd gone off for a life of leisure in the Caribbean or something and assumed your guides were now just a legacy. :cheers

Hi Peter

I've shut down our retail operations but have retained the website and update calendars and release info as often as I can (usually daily, if I'm here and can find the time!).

I have been away for 3 months "down under" - but even that is a distant memory now!!

BromsMods
Full Member


Joined: Mon Oct 15th, 2007
Location:  
Posts: 515
Status: 
Offline

My photos:
view photos in Gallery
view photos as slides

toto wrote: Hi John,

I will hopefully be starting my first decoder installation this weekend providing my decoders have arrived from Hattons. ( ordered yesterday )

I will include photo's and be as specific and clear as I can. If the posts are any good and clear enough in a manner that makes them useable, by all means help yourself.

I am a complete novice at this so I think I would wait and see the results first. :mutley

Cheers anyway

Toto

Hi Toto

Why not email what you have produced to one of our email addresses (support at bromsgrovemodels.co.uk would be a suitable one) before publishing it and I'll see if I can produce your material (with acknowledgements, of course) in our house style.

toto
Former Member
 

Joined: 
Location:  
Posts: 
Status: 
Offline

My photos:
view photos in Gallery
view photos as slides

Hi John,

I can give it a bash. Is there any specific format that the photo's should be in, ie Gif, JPG etc.

I take it there would not be a problem in me still including these in the forum posts ?

What other information would you like added, for example, decoder type, loco model references etc ?

Cheers

Toto

BromsMods
Full Member


Joined: Mon Oct 15th, 2007
Location:  
Posts: 515
Status: 
Offline

My photos:
view photos in Gallery
view photos as slides

All the images I use are JPG, but I can convert most formats.  The larger the images the better as I always put on an option to view a larger image from the thumbnail.  Annotation of images is always a good idea if you can.

As much detail as possible about installations is always a good idea - see some of the guides which are mine on the site (they don't take you to an external link) for some ideas on content.

I would expect that YMR would be pleased to have the guides as well.  The only problem with a forum based approach is the indexing/ease of location of a particular installation.

BCDR
Moderator


Joined: Sat Oct 19th, 2013
Location: Reston, Virginia USA
Posts: 3301
Status: 
Offline

My photos:
view photos in Gallery
view photos as slides

John (Bromsmods) has some nice descriptions on how to put decoders in a wide range of locomotives. I've even used them as a reference source. Those contemplating putting a decoder in themselves might want to consider the following, based on my experiences of the past 5 years (and some 75+ installations in modern and not so modern locomotives).

1. Buy good quality decoders, especially when considering sound. And never skimp on speakers.

2. Never hard-wire if at all possible. Use a wiring harness with an appropriately pinned socket. Bitter experience after frying 3 sound decoders. I use Loksound harnesses, there are others.

3. Not all "DCC Ready" models are. They may have a DCC socket and the assorted capacitors and chokes, often there is not room for anything except one of those mini, double-sided and horrendously expensive decoders. Guilty parties - Bachmann, Hornby, Heljan. I cut it all away, remove the circuit board, and hard-wire a harness. Even when I want light functions (that's what all those extra wires are for coming out of the decoder). Worst example is I think the Hornby 14xx (and from memory the Hornby 4-6-0 County).

4. Pre-DCC models have their own challenges. Some examples:

A. Hornby Dean Goods. There is (just) enough space between the backhead and boiler weight for a small decoder (TCS). Anything larger requires butchery. Take the boiler out, and using the lagest file to hand, remove metal from the top to create some space for the decoder. If sound is required the speaker(s) will go here, as there is no room in the tender. Power leads need to go to the tender, use 2 pin mini/micro pre-wired male/female connectors (e.g., those from Miniatronics or similar).

B. Bachmann Collett Goods. No room in the boiler, plenty in the tender. Use 4 pin connectors, because you don't want to have to dismantle the tender when you want to separate it from the engine. Drill small holes in the coal to allow sound to come out if installing a sound decoder.

C. Early Bachmann Warship (non-DCC model). There is no room! (not that there is very much in the DCC ready version either). Get rid of the circuit board on top, take that file again and reduce the height of the chassis over the wheel towers. If you use plenty of masking tape you don't need to dismantle the thing. Just keep the metal out of the gear towers (the motor is a sealed can anyway). You can just about get a speaker in using foam tape as the speaker box.

D). LIma GWR Diesel Railcar. Pick-up on one side of the bogie only. Not good enough for DCC. Buy a Hornby. Wait, have you seen the price of the Hornby compared to a good Lima example? Check my post in Members Workbenches for a "how to do it". With the whirrrrr from the gears you don't need  a sound decoder! If installing sound, put the speaker (and decoder for that matter) in the chassis well where the weight goes.

E. Keyser white metal kits. Bin the K's motor and wheels. Get new ones (Mashima, Markits or Gibsons).

F. Roxey "Howard" 0-4-0 diesel. This uses a Tenshodo Spud, which in DC has 2 speeds, zero and maximum. The pick-ups need to be isolated from their connection to the motor terminals. Cut, wire up, use the smallest decoder possible because there is not very much space in the body. Runs marginally better in DCC mode. Not enough torque and a low ratio (15:1).

G. Bachmann split chassis models (Manor, early 57xx, Jubilee). Assuming the axles are OK (if they're split you're sunk, check if you have erratic running, park it in a siding somewhere or get replacements from Bachmann, although not for the Manor), it can be done. The issue is getting power from either side of the split chassis. Loosen the frames so the terminals of the motor are accessible, remove the springs connecting them to either side of the chassis, solder orange/grey wires to the terminals. Glue a small piece of plastic in the hole where the spring was so the motor terminals do not short out on the frames. Dap of liquid insulation doesn't harm either. Unless you fancy soldering MAZAC (which requires aluminum solder and a very special and nasty flux) or drilling and tapping the frames for terminal screws, glue 2 wired (black, red) pieces of thin P/B or brass strip to the inside bottom of the axle cover so they connect with the frames. In the case of the Manor run the leads to the tender (drill holes as required in the chassis). Use 4-pin mini/micro male/female connectors. I've seen some very dubious methods in the model railway press, for example, solder squares of aluminum to the terminals. Aluminum, brass, hold on, that's a battery! One of them will corrode with time. In the case of the 57xx the decoder goes in the cab.

Some really easy ones. The Mainline Warship. An embarrassment of space inside. Plenty of room for a bass speaker and a regular speaker (or 3). The Heljan Western (getting the body off is the difficult bit). Plenty of room for the decoder, but the speaker needs to be in the fuel tank. Run speaker wire down through the gear tower well, drill lots of holes in the bottom of the well. Any modern tender engine (or tender without motor). Hornby Castle, 28xx, Bachmann City, etc.

Not so easy - the latest Bachmann Class 20. DCC ready, no room for a sound decoder and speaker. End driving compartments are closed boxes, making running light wiring installation a challenge. The Heljan Hymek. Where on earth is the speaker supposed to go? Shoehorn fit. No speaker case, I had to use foam tape and that after some chassis removal.

Think outside of the box. Most sound decoders will run 2 speakers with appropriate adjustment of the power. Why not a double headed Warship? I used a Bachmann warship with one speaker, and a de-motored Mainline Warship with the second speaker (an eBay purchase that didn't run that well, I removed the motor, filled the space left with lead). I have on my HO layout an F3A+B unit that is powered on the A unit with a Loksound decoder (and speaker), and has a Loksound sound unit in the non-powered B unit that is driving the circuit board, not the wheels. Two separate address that are consisted, it can only be run on half volume. I also have the GWR/BR Brown-Boveri oil turbine (Silver Fox Models) that has a QSI sound decoder driving 2 speakers (it's design to run 2) on a Bachmann Class 37 chassis. 

Many will realize right off that most of the above will invalidate any warranty. If uncomfortable with the prospect of decreasing the value of a model by at least 50% get the installation done by an expert.

DCC has been around since the mid 1970's in the UK (the whole concept came out of the University of Southampton apparently, digital command of the National Grid through the wires), IMO it's a pity that UK manufacturers have for so many years treated DCC as an afterthought, rather than an intrinsic part of the design. I can appreciate why completely retooling a diesel chassis just to accomodate DCC is a costly endevour, but tweaking it (the Bachmann Western is a prime example, as is their Class 37) by adding a DCC ready socket is often not enough. Properly designed DCC ready should mean just dropping the decoder (and speaker) in. Tender engines fortunately are an easy modification since the demise of ringfield motors.

I think it's worthwhile expanding the thread, I've certainly got a few specific examples I can share, if only to point out the pitfalls.

Nigl

Last edited on Thu Mar 13th, 2014 11:32 pm by BCDR

Ed
Full Member


Joined: Tue Jan 29th, 2013
Location: West Anglia Main Line, United Kingdom
Posts: 3822
Status: 
Offline

My photos:
view photos in Gallery
view photos as slides

Think I'll stay DC :roll:

BCDR
Moderator


Joined: Sat Oct 19th, 2013
Location: Reston, Virginia USA
Posts: 3301
Status: 
Offline

My photos:
view photos in Gallery
view photos as slides

Hi Ed,

I've described most of the hard ones (message, it can be done), and some of the easy ones. Most DCC ready locomotives (diesel and steam) are straightforward. Some of the "DCC Ready" ones were done using what was a pre-DCC chassis and a new circuit board, those have issues (not insurmountable). DCC Ready tender locomotives just require popping the body off the tender and plugging in the decoder. I enjoy getting the old stock to run under DCC (currently the oldest is a 1970's Hornby Saint), that sometimes takes a bit of ingenuity with respect to wiring and where does the decoder go? Especially with a split chassis 0-6-0 tank or pannier. With the modern, small decoders they can be fixed to the underside of an 0-6-0 cab with double sided tape and be out of site. I've even slipped them into the bunker of a Hornby 2757 pannier, which is an open cab, and the bunker of a K's 14xx.

I'm sure if you take the plunge somebody will have converted the locomotive of your choice and can point out the issues if any. Just ask. If you are running anything more than a small branch line with a single engine in steam (or in diesel) DCC is the only way to go. In my experience the older engines run better with DCC (shunting speed of 1-2 mph compared with 4-6) and with variable momentum are much more fun to drive. I only started modeling 10 ago and after a couple of years in DC went 100% into DCC (and 80% sound). No regrets. My next layout (currently a-building) will be DCC.

I'd like this thread to continue, I'm willing to provide a description of some of the conversions I've done over the years. Perhaps others can chip in (so to speak).

Nigel

BCDR
Moderator


Joined: Sat Oct 19th, 2013
Location: Reston, Virginia USA
Posts: 3301
Status: 
Offline

My photos:
view photos in Gallery
view photos as slides

Hi Toto,

Dug out the Bachmann Class 20. Mine currently has the body off as I'm converting to EM gauge, and I need to replace some of the steps and handrails. I have a sound decoder and speaker, so space is tight, as the top of the chassis cannot be reduced. The locomotive is a bit of a mongrel, I bought a Class 20 running chassis for another project which never got started, then a green body shell from Bachmann, and I used a recycled sound decoder re-blown with Class 20 sounds.

No before and after pictures. The existing circuit board was removed, along with the capacitors (the oval things) and chokes, which freed up an awful lot of space, and an 8-pin harness wired in. All electrical connections were soldered-up and insulated with heat shrink tubing (best to put this on before soldering, as I have found several times). I have a Loksound decoder that sits over one wheel gear turret (cab end) on a piece of 3M double sided foam tape on the top of the frame, then the wiring harness, then the speaker (which as you can see is a big rectangular one, size does matter here). No room for a speaker enclosure (width-wise and verically , so the back-sound is blocked with 3M double sided foam tape. Cheap and cheeful and it works. The speaker sits underneath the fan grille over the other gear tower. Quite effective. And yes, it does all fit under the body shell (just), probably a mm to spare. The decoder was recycled from a GWR Manor (steam) to the Class 20 by Howes. Highly recommended. Usual spaghetti of wires as I have plans to put in directional lighting when I figure how to get the cab off (suggestions anyone?).

The real issue is space, if you use a small mini-decoder then you should get away using the circuit board that is there. I now remove all circuit boards so I'm starting from scratch. I also stopped shortening any wires from harnesses and decoders.

I haven't been able to find any reason to keep 21 pin DCC sockets, so they go as well (why buy a space-filling adapter?) and I have used 8 pin decoders for several years now.

Nigel








toto
Former Member
 

Joined: 
Location:  
Posts: 
Status: 
Offline

My photos:
view photos in Gallery
view photos as slides

Hi Nigel,

You certainly know what you are doing that's for sure. I am a fresher to all this but I am interested in getting more confident with it.
I have a few loco's to do and to pay to have them chipped is at least £5.00 a go.
I have already done some 25's and a 37 and a couple of others and to be honest, they were not to difficult. The hardest part is usually getting the shell off. The rest is about 30 seconds work.
Again, I have never tried cutting out the socket and hard wiring as I'm not sure where all the wires would go but it is something that I think I will have to look at. Even cutting out the capacitors put shivers down my spine but the more I read on it, the more confident I feel that I would not screw it up.

I appreciate your additions to the thread, please feel free to continue all you want. I will be adding to it myself over the next coming days but it will not be as " involved" as your installations as I am not including sound ( yet ). Mines will be at the other end of the scale, the plug and plays.
Once I get my head around the wiring and what they all do, I may try hardwiring, especially where I come across some of the more space starved loco's.

I should be adding to this either tonight or tomorrow depending on when my decoders arrive from Hattons. One thing, I did not realise until lately that the 21 pin decoders were simply an interim measure. I thought that maybe the manufacturers had " plans " for the other pins. From what I now gather, 8 pin is the standard and all that is needed, even if you want to install sound. With this in mind, I may start buying 8 pin decoders and cutting away the 21 pin sockets and hard wiring, just as soon as I can work out the connections.

Once again, cheers for adding the above and don't be a stranger to the post.

Cheers

Toto

BCDR
Moderator


Joined: Sat Oct 19th, 2013
Location: Reston, Virginia USA
Posts: 3301
Status: 
Offline

My photos:
view photos in Gallery
view photos as slides

Hi Toto,

Thanks for the comments. I'm not that sure I know what I'm doing some of the time, but it seems to work most of the time! I do a fair amount of scratch building and modification of RTR locomotives, so I've got used to the idea of what I term hacking and bashing. I live in Canada, so sending a locomotive back to the UK for warranty work is just not cost effective anyway. Invalidating the warranty by removing the electrical noise suppression gear is a minor consideration. Which reminds me - I was reading recently that modern Hornby electric motors are a bit special. Found it. Taken from http://www.hornby.com/profile/1055491/. A good guide to DCC, very clear.

Motor Suppression
Hornby Locos and electrical products are certified to EU EMC (Electromagnetic Compatibility) standards; they meet or exceed laid down requirements of the standard that covers emission of RFI (Radio Frequency Interference.) The suppression of the RFI from our products is achieved by design technique and utilisation of suppression components as needed.

Electric motors suppression is achieved by fitting internally on the commutator of the motor; “varistors”. A “varistors” is a voltage dependent resistor; which suppress voltage spikes. These are electrically placed between each winding of the motor. External from the motor, it is usual to find a ferrite sleeves, chokes and a capacitor.

Decoders and Motor suppression
The Hornby ranges of decoders are designed to work with any motor suppression fitted left in place. Removal of the suppression components is not generally recommended as it will mean the item no longer meets the EMC requirement.

However, some motor suppression components and decoders in combination may cause issues with smooth running. This is usually caused by the back EMF monitoring feature built in to some decoders becoming confused. Back EMF monitoring is designed to maintain constant motor speed when the motor and loco comes under load on an incline etc. The motor suppression capacitor can affect the reading of the back EMF value thus causing unstable running. Also, faulty suppression components have been known to cause unpredictable and jerky running.

In these extreme cases of bad running you may have to remove the motor suppression components. Modern electric motors which have built in suppression components (varistors) may be fitted with sufficient suppression to keep RFI emissions within reasonable limits; without further external components. Older motors were somewhat more primitive in design and contained no internal suppression can cause problems if any suppression components external to the motor are removed.


Interesting point whether the warranty would be invalidated if Hornby's instructions were followed. All the decoders I use (except for a few Digitrax cheapies that I use for testing) have inbuilt suppression circuitry (always worth checking), and are unlikely to generate snow on the neighbors TV (assuming it's a valve one from the 1950's). I've never found that removing suppression circuitry from an old Hornby open frame affects its running with DCC. I have no idea whether the Mashima can motors I like to use have internal suppression. I doubt it.

I was also waiting for the reason why 21 pins were introduced. Nothing materialized. Well, except for the debacle with the Dapol 22 pin socket. Many decoder manufacturers such as Loksound and QSI went the other way, with double ended decoders, one end for the conventional 8-leads, the other for the additional wiring for lights and other functions. My QSI decoder in the Kerosene Can (the GWR turbine) has 14 additional wires for Mars lights, ditch lights, search lights, warning lights, etc. Plus 4 leads for the 2 speakers, which have independent volume controls. I have a few 21 pin decoders (Bachmann City for example) but am steadily standardizing on 8 pin decoders.

I noticed that you have a Bachmann Jubilee on the "to do" list. Is this the old (split frame) or the new model? If it's the old model they suffered from "split axle" syndrome where the plastic axle sleeves would fracture with age and exposure to oil. Easy to check, take the wheel set out, and have a look at the plastic axle sleeve that slides over the stub axle of the wheel. If it's cracked or split it's only a matter of time before the wheels will wobble, slip and cause motion lock. Happens normally on the gear axle, which is subject to a lot more torque than the other axles. Bachmann should still have replacement wheel sets, but the rods have to be swapped over. Peters Spares carries the plastic axles, but you have to watch the diameter of the hole as there are 2 variants. The early 57xx model (the ex-Mainline model) suffers from the same problem. Two models to keep away from when buying second hand.

I'll post a few more "problematics" over the next little while. As you are finding out most conversions are plug and play, the difficulty is getting the body off some of the diesels. A supply of wood tooth-picks is essential for some models. It's the smaller ones that are interesting and more challenging because of space constraints. I actually have a Hornby 14xx and Bachmann 56xx scheduled for DCC conversion. The 14xx I've done before, the 56xx, a GWR 0-6-2 tank engine, is new territory for me. Not new, probably "early DCC" with an 8 socket board optimistically thrown in for good luck. Large can motor with a worm/flywheel combo, which is ideal for DCC. From the diagram, space under the hood looks tight, although there may be space in the smoke box for a speaker. Large bunker though, which should take the decoder. I'll provide a blow-blow with pictures.

Nigel

toto
Former Member
 

Joined: 
Location:  
Posts: 
Status: 
Offline

My photos:
view photos in Gallery
view photos as slides

Hi Nigel,

Still trying to digest the suppression notes and will read them over until I understand it.......could take a wee while. :mutley

The jubilee was purchased about a year ago, new from Hattons. As you say I would need to remove the axle to determine which model it is but I would like to think its the latest.

I think because I only tackled some of the easy fits to date, I haven't come across any tight or awkward issues so far with regards to space. However I did have an issue with a Heljan class 47 that just seemed to come apart in my hands once the shell came of. Everything seemed to spew out to meet me. That ended up going into my local dealers to be corrected.

The more I read on this subject the more fascinating it becomes. It's amazing where you can fit a decoder.
I am just in the door and no signs of my decoders having been delivered from Hattons. Fingers crossed they come tomorrow as it will let me tackle my first conversion in a while.
I will similarly provide a blow by blow account of how I get on ( with photographs ) some of them will cover what is probably old hat and not very taxing for yourself but my idea is to build up a head of steam and so e confidence by tackling one or two easier loco's first, and progress from there.
thanks yet again for the above post. It is very informative and helps understand a bit more of the black art of suppression etc.

Cheers for now.

Toto

Petermac
Moderator


Joined: Sat Oct 13th, 2007
Location: Nr Bergerac, France
Posts: 17028
Status: 
Offline

My photos:
view photos in Gallery
view photos as slides

I've read that the Bachmann J39 (non DCC ready) is not easy to convert.  Would I be better getting rid of it (even though it's hardly done 25 metres running) ?

Also, I have a non DCC ready Bachmann Jinty I wouldn't mind chipping .............:roll::roll:  Have you done either one Nigel ?

BCDR
Moderator


Joined: Sat Oct 19th, 2013
Location: Reston, Virginia USA
Posts: 3301
Status: 
Offline

My photos:
view photos in Gallery
view photos as slides

Hi Toto,

The latest Jubilee came out last year so you should be fine as it sounds like the revamped model.The problem didn't appear for several years (age and an oil-incompatible plastic).

Nigel

toto
Former Member
 

Joined: 
Location:  
Posts: 
Status: 
Offline

My photos:
view photos in Gallery
view photos as slides

Hi Nigel,

Thanks for that, I'm glad it's not major surgery. I dare sy that will come at some point.
I'll do an up to date list of the loco's that I have to chip in case there are any more Wobblies in there.

Cheers for now.

Toto

toto
Former Member
 

Joined: 
Location:  
Posts: 
Status: 
Offline

My photos:
view photos in Gallery
view photos as slides

Here is my updated list of Loco's for chipping. I'll work my way through chipping them but as I said, due to the fact that I've just ordered 9 x 21 pin decoders, I'll be starting on them first so if there are any specific requests let me know and I will cover them.

First couple will be easy peasey ones to get me into the swing of it again. Then, take your pick. If there are any on here that require a special decoder ( mini decoder for example ) etc, pre warn me if possible.


Class A4 William Whitelaw ( Bach ) 8 pin
Class A4 Dominion of Canada ( Bach ) 8 pin
Class 37 ( Bach ) 37427 Bont Y Bermo 21 pin
Class 37 ( Bach ) 37405 Strathclyde Region 21 pin
Class 37 ( Bach ) 37412 Loch Lomond 21 pin

Class 03 ( Bach ) 03045 ( nr 2 for renumbering ) 6 pin
Class 08 ( Bach ) D3963 8 pin
Class 08 ( Bach ) D3963 ( nr 2 for renumbering ) 8 pin
Class 20 ( Bach ) 20128 21 pin
Class 22 ( Dap ) D6327 21 pin
Class 22 ( Dap ) D6311 21 pin
Class 22 ( Dap ) D6330 21 pin
Class 14 ( Hel ) D9535 8 pin
Class 33 ( Hel ) 33029 Glen Loy 8 pin
Class 53 ( Hel ) D0280 Falcon 8 pin
Class 47 ( Hel ) unnumbered 8 pin
Class 47 ( Hel ) unnumbered 8 pin
Class 47 ( Hel ) Unnumbered 8 pin
Class 47 ( Hel ) 47555 Commonwealth Spirit 8 pin
Class 25 ( Bach ) 25279 21 pin
Class 55 ( Bach ) ? pin
Class J94 ( Hor ) 68006 ? pin
Class 8750 ( Bach ) 4680 8 pin
Class Jubilee ( Bach ) 45587 8 pin
Class N ( Bach ) 31404 6 pin
Class 5MT ( Bach ) 73049 8 pin
Class 4F ( Bach ) 43924 21 pin
Class 7F ( Bach ) 53810 21 pin
Class 9F ( Bach ) 8 pin


Feel free to come back with any comments, advice, warnings etc.

cheers for now.

toto

BCDR
Moderator


Joined: Sat Oct 19th, 2013
Location: Reston, Virginia USA
Posts: 3301
Status: 
Offline

My photos:
view photos in Gallery
view photos as slides

Hi Petermac,

J39 - I've done similar. This is a split-frame chassis with zero room in the body for a decoder. It comes with a tender, so plenty of room there. The issue is isolating the motor and getting connections with the 2 chassis halves. There is normally a thin (50 micron) layer of copper underneath the paint that can with luck be soldered. MAZAC can also be soldered, but the flux and solder are not very nice. Drilled and tapped for screws or pick-ups under the frame work well (I've converted 3 different Bachmann split frames to date), wires to the tender and decoder and back to the motor.

Jinty looks straightforward to me. There is a U-tube on this

Nigel

MaxSouthOz
Admin


Joined: Sat Aug 23rd, 2008
Location: Adelaide , Australia
Posts: 12346
Status: 
Offline

My photos:
view photos in Gallery
view photos as slides

Hornby have no credibility in my book when it comes to decoders.  They are at the bottom of the pile and would never be fitted to any loco I am converting.

Admittedly, most of my work is with sound decoders - top of the pile Loksound, Zimo and QSI.  Spurious problems often link back to leaving the capacitors in place.  They serve no useful purpose.

I hard wire every decoder, stripping the loco right back.  I remake the pick ups, fit LED lights (sometimes with fibre optics), and service the drive train - including snipping off the capacitors.

I ALWAYS use "sugar cube" speakers.  They are small (15mm x 10mm), and have a huge sound due to their integrated chamber.

Loksound uses 4 Ohm amplifies, so two 8 Ohm sugar cubes in parallel, facing each other creates a mighty and bassy sound, due to the hyperbaric effect.

Did I mention removing the capacitors?  :lol:

BCDR
Moderator


Joined: Sat Oct 19th, 2013
Location: Reston, Virginia USA
Posts: 3301
Status: 
Offline

My photos:
view photos in Gallery
view photos as slides

Max,

Couldn't agree more. Hence my previous comment re getting decent decoders. Seems Hornby want us to use their decoders. I run Loksound, Loksound Select for the NA stock, QSI and Lenz mini-silvers, I have used Soundtraxx, Digitrax and the like are for making sure the wiring is correct before committing an expensive decoder. Like you I see no point in keeping circuit boards, chokes or resisters (whether it's Bachmann, Hornby, Atlas, Athearn, or Kato) when a decoder is being installed that is doing all of that and better. I think we differ in that I don't hard-wire directly. Start with a clean slate, if it goes wrong it's my fault, not some unsuspected interaction with what they did (or did not). Whenever possible I change the motor as well, as I have to change the wheel sets anyway. Slowly moving towards proper chassis' for all the stock with Mashima cans and decent gearboxes with ratios appropriate for the job.

Most of my decoders are Loksounds, after sales service is fantastic, even several years after buying.

Enough, this is Toto's thread, and I did promise a blow-by-blow of the Bachmann 56xx. Which is already proving interesting.

Nigel






toto
Former Member
 

Joined: 
Location:  
Posts: 
Status: 
Offline

My photos:
view photos in Gallery
view photos as slides

Hey Nigel,

Carry on ....... It's all over my head and I did not realise this subject ran so deep. A fascinating read.

I'll chip In to what max said about Hornby but from a much wider perspective............ I hate buying anything from them. Have a look at my loco list which tells a story. I have only detailed the unchipped loco's but out of a total of 51' two are Hornby and I have had bother with both of them.
I may have to give in again at some stage, but as far as I am concerned, hell will freeze over first. They take there name for granted and In my opinion, try to dictate the market. Well...........they have fallen from grace and on hard times and the other big three are reaping the benifits.

Sorry about the rant but I always say ......... Vote with your feet and rightly or wrongly from a personal perspective that is what I have done.

Back to chips............ I've not tinkered with sound as yet as it seems very expensive and can't justify it when I have so much still to do with the basic layout. But I would appreciate an honest breakdown of what it would cost me for the basic components to try my first sound project say on a class 37 or a 25. The big manufacturers are starting to produce loco's with sound for about £ 135 and slightly upwards, what in your opinion is the big difference from say a Zimo equipped sound decoder.

It may be night and day to an experienced modeller but to me the differences may not be that obvious.

Cheers again

Toto

BCDR
Moderator


Joined: Sat Oct 19th, 2013
Location: Reston, Virginia USA
Posts: 3301
Status: 
Offline

My photos:
view photos in Gallery
view photos as slides

Hi Toto,

Class 37 - which one? Howes have 3 different ones for £117.00. Looking at Hattons (my base reference point) a Class 37 goes for around £84.00, depending on the model. eBay is slightly cheaper. Combine the 2 and that's £201.00 for the locomotive and a full function decoder with authentic sounds (and of high fidelity). Zimo decoders would appear to be £10.00 cheaper. I have no experience of these.

Not sure where you saw one with sound for £135.00. Ah, under £130 with Soundtraxx sound on pre-order. Not bad.This is an "economy" range decoder with limited functions (no bells and whistles, which is what Bachmann believe the UK buyer wants (I have a lot of issues with this approach) compared to a regular decoder. Apparently these are recorded from the real thing. Also applies to the Class 20, 45xx, 57xx (I'd be interested in the 45xx and 57xx if the sounds are as good as the Howes ones), and the BR 5MT. 

Loksound Selects for NA sounds go for around $88.00 US, Loksound 4.00 for around $115 US, which is a lot less than in the UK. Difference is that nearly all UK sounds are proprietary, most NA sounds are in the public domain. And no, they will not re-blow a NA decoder in the UK. I've asked.

If you're not bothered by the reduced functionality of the Soundtraxx decoder and if the sound quality is good for that price it's a pretty good deal. £20.00 more than the Loksound decoder alone (although that has much more functionality).

Regards,

Nigel


toto
Former Member
 

Joined: 
Location:  
Posts: 
Status: 
Offline

My photos:
view photos in Gallery
view photos as slides

Hi,

Got my decoders from a Hattons today. Disaster........no pins, I take it these have to be soldered then. :thud

They are tiny....... Oh boy.

This could be interesting...........and costly. :mutley

I'll be back

Cheers
Toto

MaxSouthOz
Admin


Joined: Sat Aug 23rd, 2008
Location: Adelaide , Australia
Posts: 12346
Status: 
Offline

My photos:
view photos in Gallery
view photos as slides

They may have to push on to a 21 pin rack, Tom.

Are they 21 pin?

Can you put up a photo of them?

toto
Former Member
 

Joined: 
Location:  
Posts: 
Status: 
Offline

My photos:
view photos in Gallery
view photos as slides

Hi max

I'll post a photo in the morning

Cheers

Toto

Ed
Full Member


Joined: Tue Jan 29th, 2013
Location: West Anglia Main Line, United Kingdom
Posts: 3822
Status: 
Offline

My photos:
view photos in Gallery
view photos as slides

Aren't most 21 pin decoders direct plug, no harness quest:


Ed

MaxSouthOz
Admin


Joined: Sat Aug 23rd, 2008
Location: Adelaide , Australia
Posts: 12346
Status: 
Offline

My photos:
view photos in Gallery
view photos as slides

That's what I'm saying, Ed.  They push on to a rack of pins.

toto
Former Member
 

Joined: 
Location:  
Posts: 
Status: 
Offline

My photos:
view photos in Gallery
view photos as slides

Hi Max,

as promised, please see below some shots of the two decoder types. On closer inspection, I can see the holes, .........:oops: I was looking for pins which of course will be on the Loco side.:oops::oops:

Anyway, I'll post the piccies regardless.

First up is the hattons offering, as packaged



Now a close up, forgive the photo quality.



and a bit clearer on this one,




and the the Lenz Silver, as packaged,



and a couple out of the shell,



and the last one,




Sorry for the confusion, I think a blind man would have even spotted this first time around. There we have it anyway. I might get on to the first conversion tonight depending how far on I get with my tracklaying. If not, I'll pick a hand full of loco's and take them up north with me.

I'm not sure f my works laptop will let me down load photo's to it so if not, it maybe next weekend before I get them posted. Hopefully it will have the facility without needing administrators rights.

cheers for now.

Toto

MaxSouthOz
Admin


Joined: Sat Aug 23rd, 2008
Location: Adelaide , Australia
Posts: 12346
Status: 
Offline

My photos:
view photos in Gallery
view photos as slides

Hi Toto

I admit up front that I'm exclusively ESU nowadays.  My main focus is on computer control, so I have eliminated all of the hassles I can in the infrastructure that supports it.  That's the reason I'm building my own turnouts - too many issues with RTR stuff.

Anyway, I digress.  ESU offer a daughter board for 21 pin decoders, called a 21 MTC adapter.  It has all of the standard wires attached to it - including the speaker wires - and even pads for two extra auxiliary functions.  Once the daughter board is installed, it's simply a matter of pressing the 21 pin decoders on to it.

So called DCC ready locos often have these 21 pin racks on them, but they still have the issue of the capacitors and the DC board.  I really hate watching people new to DCC, struggling with the process. Eventually we all decide on a good brand and stick to it.

The best advice I can give you is to avoid brands that sell decoders as a part of their larger business.  TCS, Lenz and ESU make decoders and associated products.  You will pay a bit more for them, but it's value for money.

BCDR
Moderator


Joined: Sat Oct 19th, 2013
Location: Reston, Virginia USA
Posts: 3301
Status: 
Offline

My photos:
view photos in Gallery
view photos as slides

Hi Toto,

I just posted the Bachmann 56xx DC to DCC sound conversion I did over the weekend in Members Projects/Members Workbenches/ Nigel's Workbench as it is quite long, and I don't want to take over your post.

One of the first generation DCC "Ready" models that was really a DC chassis with an 8-pin plug as an afterthought and really no space for a decoder, let alone a decoder and a speaker.

Issues I found: Non-standard wiring, no room for a standard sized decoder in the boiler and no room for a speaker in the boiler.

I managed to squeeze a full-size decoder and a 20mm speaker in, but it turned out to be a total dismantle and rewiring job to do it. Not difficult, minimum of tools required (screwdrivers, file, soldering iron), and minimal butchery of the body work.  

I bought the model for £20.00 in excellent as new condition, soemthing those trying DCC modifications for the first time might want to consider.

Nigel



                 

Recent Topics Back to top of page

Powered by UltraBB 1.15 Copyright © 2007-2011 by Jim Hale and Data 1 Systems. Page design copyright © 2008-2013 Martin Wynne. Photo gallery copyright © 2009 David Williams.